I see consistent agreement that the giveaways should be
- Distributed among a wider group of active community members
- Not encourage point farming / head to head competition among users.
A lottery among active users with some criteria for activity fits those. I like @Duane_Lester’s simple criteria on comments.
I don’t see agreement on removing points for threads. v2 already reduced points without fixing the leaderboard, and slowed people’s ability to level up . I think because of that people are leery of suggestions that reduce the totals even further.
Any individual point reward is a small incentive and likely isn’t causing the problem here, just as it isn’t at Anker. Making those points the margin between winning a nice prize or getting nothing is what drives this I believe.